So you’re heading off on a trip and you’ve got more gear than your vehicle can carry. It’s a common problem but there are a number of options to solve that problem. With all these options, how do you choose?
The most critical question you must ask yourself is: “Where do I want to store my gear?” You’ve got two basic choices: on your vehicle’s rooftop or on your vehicle’s hitch. Below is a side-by-side comparison of rooftop cargo carriers and hitch mounted cargo carriers that will help you decide which carrier will work best for you.
Rooftop Cargo Carriers
Hitch Mounted Cargo Carriers
Gear Accessibility
May be difficult to access on large vehicles like vans, SUV’s, and RV’s
Waist-level access to gear regardless of height of vehicle
Truck Compatibility
Generally not compatible with trucks as the cab is not a large enough mounting surface.
Generally compatible with trucks
Installation Considerations
Often requires additional mounting brackets to attach and secure.
Requires a trailer hitch (already in place on most vehicles)
Cargo Capacity
Up to 20 cu.ft.
Up to 200 pounds
Up to 16 cu.ft.
Up to 200 pounds
Functional Cargo Capacity
Long and angular design will compromise the ability to carry bulky items or suitcases
Rectangular shape generally offers maximum functionality. Bulky items, suitcases fit better.
Effect on Gas Mileage
Increased drag due to rooftop location could decrease gas mileage.
Location in the slipstream behind your vehicle should not affect gas mileage.
Durability
Generally made from high-grade ABS plastic (a very light-weight yet durable material)
Generally made from higher-impact plastic polymer (extremely durable material similar to whitewater kayaks)
